Start Here
Yang Zhu illustrated by a solitary traveler on a hillside path

Yang Zhu: Concept, Texts and Interpretations

Yang Zhu illustrated by a solitary traveler on a hillside path
Explore Yang Zhu through Mencius’s single-hair example, early accounts of valuing life and the later Liezi chapter that bears his name.

Sommaire

Quick Answer: Who Was Yang Zhu?

Yang Zhu (杨朱, Yáng Zhū) is an early Chinese thinker known mostly through writings attributed to other people. Mencius (孟子, Mèngzǐ) presents him as someone who would decline to sacrifice even one hair to benefit the world. Other sources and later interpretations give attention to the value of preserving life. The received Liezi (列子, Lièzǐ) contains a chapter that bears his name.[1][2][3][4]

  • Mencius: The single-hair example is part of a criticism.
  • Valuing life: Related accounts examine what a person should be willing to surrender for status, wealth or the expectations of others.
  • The Liezi: The later chapter is evidence for a portrayal of Yang Zhu and his reception.[1][2][3][4]

Each source answers a different question about the figure or the ideas attached to him.

Yang Zhu guide to Mencius preserving life and the later Liezi chapter
Yang Zhu guide to Mencius preserving life and the later Liezi chapter

The famous example asks whether a very small personal sacrifice can be justified by a large benefit to others. Before deciding what answer Yang Zhu gave, it is worth noticing that the version most readers encounter comes from a critic.

What Mencius Does With the Example of One Hair

In 7A.26, Mencius places Yang Zhu beside Mozi, whose commitment to benefit the world is described in opposite terms. The refusal to surrender one hair gives the exchange a vivid boundary case. It lets Mencius characterize a position with one memorable example while making his own argument about rigid extremes.[1][2]

The passage gives direct evidence for Mencius’s portrayal. It leaves fewer grounds for deciding how Yang Zhu would have explained the refusal or how he would have treated other cases. The comparison with Mohist universal care is especially useful when both positions are read with the arguments of the works that transmit them.[1][2][4]

Why the Preservation of Life Matters

Some early material associated with Yang Zhu or with a related current of thought gives priority to preserving life over the pursuit of external rewards. The issue changes if a person is being asked to risk their life or bodily integrity in exchange for a prize they do not value. Valuing life can give a reason to question the demand as well as the supposed reward.[2][4]

This way of reading the material gives a reader more to consider than the label “egoism.” An argument about how far a person should allow others to claim their body or labor differs from an account of what they owe to everyone around them. The surviving evidence has led scholars to emphasize different aspects of the early tradition.[2][4]

How to Read the Yang Zhu Chapter of the Liezi

The received Liezi preserves a chapter named for Yang Zhu that discusses life, death and the enjoyments people pursue. Its literary setting and transmission matter, as they do for other texts linked to early Daoist traditions. It belongs to a composite text with a complicated history. A reader can use it to understand a later presentation of the figure and consider its arguments in their own right.[2][3]

The chapter does not resolve the historical source problem. Similarities between an episode there and the portrayal in Mencius can make comparison worthwhile. The comparison still has to distinguish what the earlier polemic says from what the received chapter makes of the figure.[1][2][3]

FAQs About Yang Zhu

Was Yang Zhu an egoist?

Some readers use the label for the position Mencius attacks. Other readings emphasize the preservation of life and resistance to demands that sacrifice it. The limited record makes the specific source important.[1][2][4]

Did Yang Zhu write the chapter named after him?

The title shows that the received work links the material to Yang Zhu. The history of the Liezi leaves authorship and the ages of its materials as separate questions.[2][3]

Was Yang Zhu a Daoist?

Some histories connect ideas attributed to him with the preservation of life in early Daoist thought. That connection helps trace themes across texts while leaving the identity of the historical figure open.[2][3][4]

Sources

[1] Mencius. Book 7A, Including Passage 26

[2] JSTOR. The Many Lives of Yang Zhu: A Historical Overview

[3] Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Liezi

[4] Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Individualism in Classical Chinese Thought